.

5 Signs You're Working With a Top Digital Marketing Agency

Molly Berard • December 16, 2020

As with most things in life, not all digital marketing agencies are created equal. There are plenty out there who make big claims, only to take your money and run! If you're working with an agency, take a look for these five things that you'll find in all of the top options!

A group of people are standing in front of a whiteboard talking to each other.
Many businesses come to us and are wary of signing on with yet another digital agency. Why? Because they've been burned before! The unfortunate truth is that many "agencies" are far from professional. Just about anyone can get into the business, and freelancers are growing rapidly in number. However, your business deserves the highest-quality work available. If you want to know if you're working with a reputable company, check out these five things that are true about all of the top digital marketing agencies!

They Personalize Your Package Based On Your Goals

A blurred image of a table with a lot of text on it

First and foremost, top digital agencies will listen to you carefully and figure out what your main goals are in working with them. This is typically accomplished via a form, meeting, or both! Once the agency hears you out, they should handpick the services that would be most beneficial to you. A less-than-stellar agency will have cookie-cutter packages that include everything but the kitchen sink. The best digital marketers will create custom packages, even if they're a bit smaller, to tailor them exactly to your needs. How can you be sure that your package is well thought out? Do a bit of research on your own into the platforms to have a vague idea of what they're good for. You can also ask the agency to explain why they chose those platforms/services. If they can't give you detailed answers, it's probably because they don't have a real answer to give you! If that's the case, it's time to find a new agency!

They Offer Services Across A Variety of Platforms

In addition to making sure that your package was made for you specifically, you also want to take a look at the services the agency offers in general. Are they well-versed across the digital sphere, or do they only know how to handle the basic platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter? You don't want to work with people who claim to be professionals only to end up having no idea what's happening. There's so much more to digital marketing than social media. You deserve to work with a company that knows how to handle ads, SEO, web development, digital optimization, blog writing, and more! Top digital marketing agencies have experience working in a huge variety of online platforms. The more experience they have, the more opportunities you'll have to get services that can boost your business! For example, if you're a hospitality company, you want to find an agency who's worked with TripAdvisor, HomeAdvisor, Yelp, and other hospitality-specific websites. Contrary to popular belief, you don't need to find a "special agency," just a well-established and reputable one!

They Have A Strong Portfolio Of Past Successes

A graph showing the number of followers on a website

Nothing helps you feel more confident than seeing that the company you're working with has seen success in the past! The top digital marketing agencies will all have portfolios readily available for potential clients to see. Many will post them right on their website! They typically include stats from past advertising campaigns, website examples, content examples, increase in sales numbers, etc. Some digital agencies will show you portfolios upon request. They may have them created for each industry so that all the information is relevant for you! Remember; past successes include awards the agency's won too! You'll want to pay attention to how recent the awards were won. Much like peer reviewed articles, as time goes on, the information becomes less relevant. It's much more impressive to see awards given every year than it is to see one award from ten years ago. As you would imagine, any company that gets awards will flash them around! If you aren't seeing accolades, they probably aren't there!

They Are Transparent With Their Clients

Is your agency constantly giving you the run-around, or are they open to talk whenever you need it? The former is a problem in all circumstances. You wouldn't stay friends with someone who constantly lied to you or withheld information would you? Then why would you work with a digital agency that did?! Transparency is key in trust building. You're handing over control of your brand (as well as a good sum of money) to your agency, you should be able to know what's going on with it! The top digital marketing agencies will always be happy to share information with you regarding your ad spend, new ideas, creative, etc. If you are being left on read and can never seem to get answers, then it's time to find a new agency!

You Are More Than Just A Number

A woman is shaking hands with a man at a table.

Lastly, you should be more than just a client to your digital team. Agencies who have hundreds of clients and a small team can't possibly take the time they need to to really understand your brand. You shouldn't just be Client 152, you're a brand with a name and a person with a name. If your team is constantly missing the mark for branding or failing to meet your expectations, it's time to have a chat with them. Obviously, an agency will have multiple clients at one time. It's their responsibility, however, to ensure that they don't bite off more than they can chew. If they are bringing in a ton of clients, that means they only want your money, they don't truly care about helping you to succeed. Your account manager should know your account inside and out, and should know you on a more personal level. Working with an agency is a relationship, and if it's only superficial, it won't last. You don't have to settle for an agency that doesn't really care if you grow or not, so don't be afraid to hunt around for a better fit!

Do you see these five things in your digital marketing agency? You should! We believe that all clients deserve the best treatment and service possible. If you're ready to switch to an agency that will work not just with you, but for you, check out BusySeed! Our team has helped to grow over 300 brands across many industries! We can customize a package to help you reach your goals. Call us today to get started, and check out our website for past successes and accolades! Call (888) 353-1484.

A row of blue mountains on a white background.
By Michael Brooker April 23, 2025
A/B testing is a game-changer for email marketing, but knowing what to test and how to analyze results is key. Explore the essential elements to test, from subject lines to calls to action, and how the data can help you optimize your email campaigns for higher conversions.
The science of subject lines : how to increase open rates
By Michael Brooker April 23, 2025
Unlock the secret to increasing open rates with subject lines that get noticed! Learn the strategies behind crafting attention-grabbing subject lines that boost open rates and drive engagement with your audience.
Remarketing techniques done right : how to win back lost customers
By Michael Brooker April 18, 2025
Mastering remarketing techniques is essential for any business looking to win back lost customers and maximize their ad spend. Investing in retargeting campaigns with targeted segmentation, optimized ad creatives, and multi-channel strategies will help you stay ahead of the competition.
By Michael Brooker April 16, 2025
Google and Bing Ads each have unique advantages, but the key to success lies in optimizing for the right audience. Learn how to refine your targeting, ad copy, and bidding strategies to boost conversions on both platforms.
By Michael Brooker April 14, 2025
Boosting your e-commerce store's visibility is all about mastering SEO. In this post, we’ll show you how to implement effective strategies that drive traffic, increase sales, and elevate your online presence, much like the leading advertising agencies in New York.
How to optimize your website content for seo success
By Michael Brooker April 11, 2025
Optimizing your content is key to standing out in search results. Learn actionable strategies to fine-tune your website’s content, boost SEO performance, and improve your online visibility, just like the best NYC advertising agencies do.
Unlocking the power of ai : practical strategies for smarter campaigns
By Michael Brooker April 9, 2025
AI is transforming how we run marketing campaigns, and it’s time to unlock its full potential. Explore simple yet effective strategies for integrating AI into your campaigns, helping you achieve more imaginative, more targeted results, just like the top NYC advertising agencies.
By Michael Brooker April 7, 2025
In AI marketing, finding the sweet spot between personalization and privacy can feel tricky. Let’s dive into how you can use AI to tailor experiences without crossing privacy lines, just like the leading agencies in New York do.
How to Build a Lead Generation Funnel That Converts
By Michael Brooker April 4, 2025
Building a lead generation funnel doesn’t have to be complicated! Let’s break it down and show you how to guide your leads through every stage—whether it’s awareness, interest, or conversion—just like the top NYC agencies do.
Show More