Lindsay Walker • May 1, 2019

To Yelp or Not to Yelp... That is the Question!

A man in a blue shirt and tie is pointing at a star that says to yelp or not to yelp that is the question

If you are a local business, there is a good chance your customers have reviewed you on Yelp. Business owners everywhere typically have a love/hate relationship with Yelp and for good reason. Yelp is essentially your local businesses reputation. So, when customers are less than enthused with your special of the day or new summer hours they will let you know.

What can you do? Participate. Become an active business owner and either take on the role of reputation manager or get the assistance of professionals…ahem. Whomever your choice, it is important to stay active on Yelp and respond to all reviews good & bad.

#1 The Good, The Bad & The Ugly

Not all Yelp reviews are glittering examples of your customers opinions. Typically Yelp Reviews are either really great or really bad and it is your responsibility to respond courteously to all of them. How you handle a negative review on Yelp could determine whether or not the customer will return. There will be individuals that have their minds made up about your business, but there is always an opportunity to get them back. You will be surprised how often an apology can turn a situation around. Keep in mind the customer is right and that their opinion counts, as they are the ones spending their hard earned money at your establishment.

Responding to good reviews is another great way to maintain your reputation. Just because they aren’t complaining doesn’t mean they don’t like some tender care from their favorite local business. Thank them for the review and ask them if there is anything else you can do to enhance their experience in the future. It’s short, simple and always effective.

#2 Keep Your Cool

Confrontation is not something you are looking to stir up on Yelp. Although you may feel hurt by your customers responses, it is important to stay cool. Getting upset will not help your situation in any way.

What to do if you don’t agree with the review? As this is your business you can proceed as you want, but as professional reputation managers we highly suggest turning down your pride. At the end of the day you want a returning customer and although you may be thinking it is just one individual, they have a network of friends whom they can tell about their experience. Try to mend the customer/business relationship if possible in order to keep your reputation in check.

#3 Message Your Heart Out

The best way to handle a tough Yelp situation is to use the private message feature. This allows you to speak with your customer one on one and to take the opportunity to change their opinion. If you want to offer a gift certificate or coupon for the customer to try you again this is the time and the place to do it. If you have the ability to offer wronged customers an incentive to visit again and potentially change their review it is worth it.

Yelp is now an important aspect of your business. Along with social media, reputation management is key when it comes to the success of a local business. So, if you are ready to get on Yelp and start talking directly with your customer base, kudos! If you are still hesitant than be sure to get in touch so we can help your business become Yelp friendly and find out more here!

A row of blue mountains on a white background.
By Michael Brooker July 4, 2025
When it comes to local lead generation for home service companies, the road to success is often filled with costly mistakes. It's all too common for businesses to pour thousands of dollars into ads, only to see minimal returns. So, why does this happen?
By Michael Brooker July 2, 2025
Discover how top AI tools used by digital marketing agencies Los Angeles—like BusySeed—help home service companies slash cost per lead (CPL) by up to 50% through lead scoring, smart scheduling, automation, and more.
By Michael Brooker June 30, 2025
Discover how social media for small business marketing can drive growth for home service pros. Learn strategies from one of the top nyc advertising agencies, BusySeed.
By Michael Brooker June 27, 2025
Discover how BusySeed, one of the top NYC advertising agencies, helped a contractor generate leads at just $6.12 per CPL using Google PPC ad strategies. Learn our bidding tactics, targeting, and budget structure.
By Michael Brooker June 25, 2025
Discover how local contractors can use content clusters and interlinking to dominate niche markets. Learn smart SEO search optimization strategies, boost long-tail rankings, and reduce ad costs. Explore next-gen digital marketing with BusySeed.
By Michael Brooker June 23, 2025
Ask any experienced marketer, and they'll tell you: high lead volume is excellent, but quality leads are what truly drive revenue. For many New York ad agencies and business owners, success isn't just about getting attention. It's about converting that attention into real business outcomes.
By Michael Brooker June 20, 2025
Discover how predictive AI and analytics help home service brands generate better leads faster. Learn how AI segments audiences, personalizes content, and improves ROI.
By Michael Brooker June 18, 2025
Discover how local brands, especially in home services, can turn clicks into conversions using top paid social strategies like retargeting, lookalike audiences, and UGC ads—straight from the playbook of one of the top NYC advertising agencies, BusySeed.
By Michael Brooker June 16, 2025
Discover how local brands, especially in home services, can turn clicks into conversions using top paid social strategies like retargeting, lookalike audiences, and UGC ads—straight from the playbook of one of the top NYC advertising agencies, BusySeed.
Show More